General relativity and cosmology



Calvin & Hobbes

Cosmology: Kinematics

Assume universe is Means metric cannot depend on θ and φ, and at any time the curvature K(t) is the same everywhere. Friedmann-Robertson-Walker

Warning

Notation: books differ on the metric.


Ryden

Ryden uses
  1. a dimensionless scale factor \color{red}{a(t)}
  2. two choices for the FRW metric
  3. r and x are two choices for the "co-moving coord." defined with respect to local frame (draw a grid on the balloon). Both have dimensions of length
  4. The metric is defined in terms of proper distance ds
    \color{red}{ ds^2 = - c^2 dt^2 + a\left( t \right)^2 \left( {\frac{{dx^2 }}{{\left( {1 - \kappa \frac{{x^2 }}{{R_0^2 }}} \right)}} + x^2 d\Omega ^2 } \right)}
    (Ω is the solid angle)
  5. or
    \color{red}{ ds^2 = - c^2 dt^2 + a\left( t \right)^2 \left( {dr^2 + r^2 S_\kappa \left( r \right)d\Omega ^2 } \right),S_\kappa \left( r \right) = \left\{ {\begin{array}{*{20}c} {R\sin \left( {r/R} \right)(\kappa = 1)} \\ {r(\kappa = 0)} \\ {R\sinh \left( {r/R} \right)(\kappa = - 1)} \\ \end{array}} \right.}
Berry (and most other books) uses
  1. a scale factor \color{red}{R(t)} with dimensions of length:
  2. the dimensionless σ is the "co-moving coord." defined with respect to local frame.
  3. so
    \color{red}{ R(t) = R_0^{} a\left( t \right)}
    and
    \color{red}{ \sigma = \frac{x}{{R_0^{} }}}
  4. a metric in terms of the proper time
    \color{red}{ d\tau ^2 = dt^2 - \frac{{R\left( t \right)^2 }}{{c^2 }}\left( {\frac{{d\sigma ^2 }}{{\left( {1 - \kappa \sigma ^2 } \right)}} + \sigma ^2 d\Omega ^2 } \right)}
These all describe the same curved space, so are equivalent for any physical measurement (they'd better be!)

e.g. d(t) is the proper distance (i.e. the actual distance to a galaxy if you could measure it instantaneously;

  1. Berry has $$ \color{red}{ d_p \left( t \right) = a\left( t \right)\int_0^{r '} {\frac{{dr }}{{\sqrt {1 - \kappa \sigma ^2 } }}} }$$ (similar argument to radius of circle. Immediately get
    \color{red}{ d_p \left( t \right) = \left\{ {\begin{array}{*{20}c} {R(t)\sin ^{ - 1} \left( \sigma \right)(\kappa = 1)} \\ {R(t)\sigma (\kappa = 0)} \\ {R(t)\sinh ^{ - 1} \left( \sigma \right)(\kappa = - 1)} \\ \end{array}} \right.}
  2. Ryden has
    \color{red}{ d_p \left( t \right) = \left\{ {\begin{array}{*{20}c} {a(t)R_0 \sin ^{ - 1} \left( {x/R_0 } \right)(\kappa = 1)} \\ {a(t)x(k = 0)} \\ {a(t)R_0 \sinh ^{ - 1} \left( {x/R_0 } \right)(k = - 1)} \\ \end{array}} \right.}
  3. or \color{red}{d(t) = ra(t)}


FRW

So the velocity of a galaxy (measurable)
\color{red}{ v = \dot d_p \left( t \right) = H\left( t \right)d_p \left( t \right) = \frac{{\dot a\left( t \right)}}{{a\left( t \right)}}d_p \left( t \right) = \frac{{\dot R\left( t \right)}}{{R\left( t \right)}}d_p \left( t \right)}
so Hubble's constant
\color{red}{ H_0 = H\left( {t_o } \right) = \frac{{\dot a\left( {t_o } \right)}}{{a\left( {t_o } \right)}} = \frac{{\dot R\left( {t_o } \right)}}{{R\left( {t_o } \right)}}}
Note
  1. the magic of factoring into scale dependent part and co-moving part.
  2. in most calculations of observables, the R0 will cancel out

Time, distance and red-shift

All very well, but we cannot observe a(t) : we can observe red-shift?

At time t₀, a galaxy is at a distance d₀ from us, and is travelling at v

We see the photon at time t1


(Note we have made a subtle change in the description: it is not the other galaxy which is moving away, it is the space in between which is stretching!)